In this soulful and spooky episode, Nick and Jess are joined by their friend and fellow improv performer Catie for a conversation that touches on everything from comedy and ghost stories to the mysteries of reincarnation and spiritual energy. Together, they share chilling tales of supernatural encounters from a grandmother’s spirit appearing on a familiar road, to a haunting drive involving a tan pickup truck that wouldn’t disappear. Along the way, the group also gets personal discussing faith, loss, life lessons, and the power of love and community to keep dark forces at bay. 👻 From dark roads and light-up dolls to Smashing Pumpkins and Dante’s Inferno, this episode proves that even the weirdest stories connect us in the most unexpected ways.

More about our Guest Catie:
Catie is a Long Island native with a deep appreciation for the spooky and the spiritual. A former criminal justice student turned improv performer, she brings a sharp wit with her amazing improv and a love of storytelling to every stage she steps on. After meeting her husband at the University at Buffalo, Catie’s journey took her from New York to Pennsylvania and Philly, with stops in East Meadow and Montauk, before returning upstate when her husband and brother-in-law took over Fox’s Deli in Henrietta. With a lifelong curiosity about the paranormal and a talent for comedy, Catie blends heart, humor, and a healthy dose of the unexplained wherever she goes.

We Need Your Terrifying Tales

Share your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at thatsoundsterrifying@gmail.com

The That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:
That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying. 

Copyright & Credits:

This podcast includes the original works and interviews by Nick and Jess and is considered the property of That Sounds Terrific Productions, LLC. Reposts and use of this content in whole or part must be credited to the hosts and That Sounds Terrifying Podcast.

That Sounds Terrifying A Podcast with Nick and Jess Art Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan,  mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site.

Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.

Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:
https://soundcloud.com/

Individual Sound effects Used  or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at https://freesound.org/ and www.101soundboards.com 

Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGpT and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use.